Upgrade from XP Home to Vista Home Premium Walt 5/23/2007 2:58:02 AM I'm planning an XP Home>Vista Home Premium upgrade and I'd like to verify my upgrade plan. I verified my PC meets Vista upgrade requirements. XP is currently installed on C: with all other programs and My Documents installed on E: After I back up any IE and Outlook data, I want to format my C drive, make my CD drive rebootable, insert the Vista upgrade, reboot, insert my XP CD to verify I have a licensed version of XP, then install Vista to C from my CD drive and re-install any programs, which I'll delete and reinstall on E. Does it look like I've covered all the steps and is this an acceptable way to upgrade to Vista? I want to accomplish a clean install. Thank you

Re: Upgrade from XP Home to Vista Home Premium "Mr. Arnold" <MR. Arnold[ at ]Arnold.com> 5/23/2007 3:12:45 AM [Quoted Text] > > Does it look like I've covered all the steps and is this an acceptable way > to upgrade to Vista? I want to accomplish a clean install. > You can boot off the Vista upgrade CD and wipe out XP, which is the better of the two options of fresh install and an upgrade over XP. Is the machine compatible to run Vista? There is a tool you can run from XP to check a machine for Vista compatibility.

Re: Upgrade from XP Home to Vista Home Premium Don <don195702[ at ]hotmail.com> 5/23/2007 3:42:27 AM Walt wrote: [Quoted Text] > I'm planning an XP Home>Vista Home Premium upgrade and I'd like to verify my > upgrade plan. I verified my PC meets Vista upgrade requirements. > > XP is currently installed on C: with all other programs and My Documents > installed on E: > > After I back up any IE and Outlook data, I want to format my C drive, make > my CD drive rebootable, insert the Vista upgrade, reboot, insert my XP CD to > verify I have a licensed version of XP... I could be mistaken because I didn't install Vista as an upgrade, but my understanding is that you must run the Vista install DVD from a working install of XP. I believe there is no option during the install to enter any proof of ownership for XP. You can, however, do a fresh install without entering a product key if you have enough free disk space. You then have 30 days to decide whether Vista is right for you before activating with your upgrade key. Most folks here feel that a clean install of Vista is safer than an upgrade on top of XP.

Re: Upgrade from XP Home to Vista Home Premium "...winston" <merlin[ at ]druid9#.com> 5/23/2007 4:17:01 AM Almost....sentence two is not entirely correct. See these links. http://www.google.com/search?q=clean+install+vista+upgrade+cd "Don" <don195702[ at ]hotmail.com> wrote in message news:eFlYoxOnHHA.4896[ at ]TK2MSFTNGP02.phx.gbl... : You can, however, do a fresh install without entering a product key if : you have enough free disk space. You then have 30 days to decide whether Vista is right for you before activating with your upgrade key. : : Most folks here feel that a clean install of Vista is safer than an : upgrade on top of XP. : :

Re: Upgrade from XP Home to Vista Home Premium "Rock" <Rock[ at ]nospam.net> 5/23/2007 4:30:31 AM "Walt" wrote [Quoted Text] > I'm planning an XP Home>Vista Home Premium upgrade and I'd like to verify > my > upgrade plan. I verified my PC meets Vista upgrade requirements. > > XP is currently installed on C: with all other programs and My Documents > installed on E: > > After I back up any IE and Outlook data, I want to format my C drive, make > my CD drive rebootable, insert the Vista upgrade, reboot, insert my XP CD > to > verify I have a licensed version of XP, then install Vista to C from my CD > drive and re-install any programs, which I'll delete and reinstall on E. > > Does it look like I've covered all the steps and is this an acceptable way > to upgrade to Vista? I want to accomplish a clean install. No, the upgrade process in Vista is different than that for XP. Vista does not do a shiny media check to verify ownership of a qualifying OS. The upgrade is designed to be started from the desktop of the installed qualifying OS. In this case from the XP desktop you would insert the Vista DVD and run the installation. There is a way around this, to do a clean install onto a bare drive from an upgrade version of Vista. It requires two installs in a row. In the first you don't provide a product key, then you do an upgrade of that Vista install with the same CD and provide the product key. See this link: http://www.dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=5932 -- Rock [MS-MVP User/Shell]

Re: Upgrade from XP Home to Vista Home Premium Walt 5/23/2007 12:57:01 PM I'm certainly glad I asked before starting the install. Looks like I can format C to wipe out XP and do the Vista install twice for a clean install. Thanks for everyone's input. Great feedback! "Rock" wrote: [Quoted Text] > "Walt" wrote > > I'm planning an XP Home>Vista Home Premium upgrade and I'd like to verify > > my > > upgrade plan. I verified my PC meets Vista upgrade requirements. > > > > XP is currently installed on C: with all other programs and My Documents > > installed on E: > > > > After I back up any IE and Outlook data, I want to format my C drive, make > > my CD drive rebootable, insert the Vista upgrade, reboot, insert my XP CD > > to > > verify I have a licensed version of XP, then install Vista to C from my CD > > drive and re-install any programs, which I'll delete and reinstall on E. > > > > Does it look like I've covered all the steps and is this an acceptable way > > to upgrade to Vista? I want to accomplish a clean install. > > No, the upgrade process in Vista is different than that for XP. Vista does > not do a shiny media check to verify ownership of a qualifying OS. The > upgrade is designed to be started from the desktop of the installed > qualifying OS. In this case from the XP desktop you would insert the Vista > DVD and run the installation. > > There is a way around this, to do a clean install onto a bare drive from an > upgrade version of Vista. It requires two installs in a row. In the first > you don't provide a product key, then you do an upgrade of that Vista > install with the same CD and provide the product key. See this link: > > http://www.dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=5932 > > -- > Rock [MS-MVP User/Shell] > >

Re: Upgrade from XP Home to Vista Home Premium "Rock" <Rock[ at ]nospam.net> 5/23/2007 9:46:22 PM You're welcome, Walt. -- Rock [MS-MVP User/Shell] "Walt" wrote [Quoted Text] > I'm certainly glad I asked before starting the install. Looks like I can > format C to wipe out XP and do the Vista install twice for a clean > install. > > Thanks for everyone's input. Great feedback! > > "Rock" wrote: > >> "Walt" wrote >> > I'm planning an XP Home>Vista Home Premium upgrade and I'd like to >> > verify >> > my >> > upgrade plan. I verified my PC meets Vista upgrade requirements. >> > >> > XP is currently installed on C: with all other programs and My >> > Documents >> > installed on E: >> > >> > After I back up any IE and Outlook data, I want to format my C drive, >> > make >> > my CD drive rebootable, insert the Vista upgrade, reboot, insert my XP >> > CD >> > to >> > verify I have a licensed version of XP, then install Vista to C from my >> > CD >> > drive and re-install any programs, which I'll delete and reinstall on >> > E. >> > >> > Does it look like I've covered all the steps and is this an acceptable >> > way >> > to upgrade to Vista? I want to accomplish a clean install. >> >> No, the upgrade process in Vista is different than that for XP. Vista >> does >> not do a shiny media check to verify ownership of a qualifying OS. The >> upgrade is designed to be started from the desktop of the installed >> qualifying OS. In this case from the XP desktop you would insert the >> Vista >> DVD and run the installation. >> >> There is a way around this, to do a clean install onto a bare drive from >> an >> upgrade version of Vista. It requires two installs in a row. In the >> first >> you don't provide a product key, then you do an upgrade of that Vista >> install with the same CD and provide the product key. See this link: >> >> http://www.dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=5932

Re: Upgrade from XP Home to Vista Home Premium Don <don195702[ at ]hotmail.com> 6/22/2007 3:27:49 AM Walt wrote: [Quoted Text] > I'm planning an XP Home>Vista Home Premium upgrade and I'd like to verify my > upgrade plan. I verified my PC meets Vista upgrade requirements. > > XP is currently installed on C: with all other programs and My Documents > installed on E: > > After I back up any IE and Outlook data, I want to format my C drive... While I like Vista, I'm compelled to say that many people have had less pleasant experiences with it than I have. There are still bugs and problems which need fixing, so to burn your bridges by doing a reformat of your XP partition is very risky. At a minimum you should do a complete backup of your XP with a product like Acronis True Image or the like, before you reformat. Be warned! BTW, technically your upgrade product key requires that you start the upgrade process from inside XP rather than doing a new install from the DVD. (There are workarounds available which can be found with a google search.)